Practice Focus

Catastrophic Injury & Wrongful Death

Serious cases. Permanent consequences. A perspective built from 18 years representing the other side.

Since late 2023, Jennifer’s practice has been devoted to representing individuals and families in catastrophic injury and wrongful death matters. Approximately 90% of her current work is plaintiff-side injury and wrongful death litigation across Arizona. The remaining 10% is a limited number of mediations and arbitrations in injury cases where she serves as a neutral.

The cases that define her practice are the ones where the injury is permanent, the loss is irreversible, and what comes next will shape a family’s life for years. Complex transportation crashes, serious premises liability, medical malpractice, and wrongful death claims in Maricopa County Superior Court and across Arizona’s counties.

Representation in these matters is handled through Zwillinger Wulkan in Phoenix. That profile is the best place to start a conversation about representation.

90%
Plaintiff-side injury and wrongful death
35+
First-chair jury trials, 5 Arizona counties
20+
Years of civil litigation experience
<2%
Of Arizona personal injury attorneys hold board certification

Understanding the case types at the center of this practice

Catastrophic Injury
In Arizona civil litigation, a catastrophic injury is permanent and life-altering: traumatic brain injury, spinal cord damage, severe burns, amputation, or any harm that fundamentally changes a person’s capacity to live and work. These cases are distinguished by the long-term medical, financial, and personal consequences they impose, and they require a lawyer who understands not just liability, but the full scope of what has been lost.
Wrongful Death in Arizona
A wrongful death claim is a civil action brought by the survivors of a person killed through the negligence or misconduct of another. Arizona law allows surviving spouses, children, and other dependents to seek compensation for the financial and personal losses caused by the death. The statute of limitations in Arizona is generally two years from the date of death. These are among the most consequential matters in civil litigation, both in what is at stake and what the work demands.
Large-Loss Matters
Jennifer focuses on large-loss matters: cases where the damages are substantial, the consequences are permanent, and the work requires someone who has tried them from both sides of the courtroom. Complex transportation crashes, serious premises liability, and medical malpractice. These cases typically involve corporate defendants, commercial carriers, and well-resourced insurers with experienced defense teams. That is exactly the environment Jennifer spent eighteen years working in.
Case Focus

Where the Practice Is Concentrated

Jennifer’s plaintiff practice centers on large-loss matters in Arizona, cases where the consequences are permanent and the work requires someone who has tried them from both sides of the courtroom.

Primary Focus
Catastrophic Injury
Serious, permanent injuries caused by the negligence of another person, company, or institution: traumatic brain injury, spinal cord injury, severe burns, amputation, and other lasting harm. Cases where the path forward requires a lawyer who understands what the other side is building, because she spent eighteen years building it.
Primary Focus
Wrongful Death
Civil claims brought by the survivors of a person killed through the negligence or misconduct of another. Among the most consequential matters in civil litigation, both in what is at stake and what the work demands. Jennifer approaches these cases with the gravity they require and the preparation they deserve.
Complex Transportation
Motor Vehicle and Trucking
Serious injuries and deaths from motor vehicle crashes, commercial trucking accidents, and other transportation cases across Arizona. Matters involving commercial carriers and corporate defendants are a particular area of depth given Jennifer’s eighteen years of defense experience on that side.
Premises
Premises Liability
Injuries on another’s property, in commercial, residential, or institutional settings, where the condition of the premises was a contributing cause. These cases frequently involve property owners, insurers, and corporate entities with established defense teams. Jennifer’s background on that side informs how she builds and presents these claims.
Medical
Medical Malpractice
Claims arising from the negligence of healthcare providers: physicians, hospitals, and other medical professionals. Complex, expert-intensive litigation requiring a lawyer with the patience to build the case and the trial experience to try it. Jennifer handles a select number of serious medical malpractice matters.
Limited Availability
Mediation and Arbitration
Jennifer serves as a neutral mediator and arbitrator in personal injury and wrongful death matters on a limited basis, approximately 10% of her current practice. Her experience representing both sides of these cases makes her an effective neutral where the factual and legal issues are complex.

Defense-Trained. Plaintiff-Driven.

Eighteen years on the other side

Before Jennifer began representing injured people and families, she spent eighteen years representing the institutions on the other side of those cases. Thirteen years as captive counsel for a major insurance company. Six more as a civil defense litigator representing businesses and insurers in complex civil litigation across Arizona.

That experience was not a detour. It was an education in exactly how cases are built against injured people: how insurance carriers evaluate claims, where they look for weaknesses, what motivates their decisions about resolution, and how they prepare their lawyers to fight. She has sat in those rooms, made those evaluations, and knows the playbook because she wrote versions of it for nearly two decades.

Since transitioning to plaintiff work in late 2023, that knowledge has been entirely in the service of the people she represents. It shapes how she builds cases, how she prepares for trial, and how she reads what the other side is likely to do next.

She brings the perspective of a former defense litigator to injured individuals and families. That perspective now informs how she builds cases and provides invaluable insights into case strategy and resolution.

2005 to 2017
Captive Insurance Defense Counsel
Thirteen years representing a major insurance carrier in civil litigation across Arizona. Inside knowledge of how carriers evaluate, manage, and resolve personal injury claims.
2017 to 2023
Civil Defense Litigator
Six years representing businesses and insurers as outside defense counsel. Complex civil litigation in Maricopa County Superior Court and across Arizona, including 35+ first-chair jury trials.
2023 to Present
Plaintiff Counsel and Neutral
Senior Counsel at Zwillinger Wulkan in Phoenix, focused on catastrophic injury and wrongful death. Approximately 90% plaintiff-side litigation, 10% neutral ADR in injury matters.
2020 to Present
Board-Certified Specialist
Certified by the State Bar of Arizona in Personal Injury and Wrongful Death, a designation held by fewer than 2% of Arizona personal injury attorneys.
Board Certified Specialist, State Bar of Arizona

Board-Certified Specialist in Personal Injury & Wrongful Death

Board of Legal Specialization · Held since 2020

What Certification Requires

  • Documented trial experience
  • Peer review from judges and opposing counsel
  • Written examination
  • Ongoing continuing legal education

Board certification in Personal Injury and Wrongful Death is an independently administered credential requiring documented trial experience, peer review, and a written examination. It is held by fewer than 2% of Arizona personal injury attorneys. Jennifer Rebholz has held it since 2020 and also chaired the State Bar Task Force that modernized the program in 2024.

Full credential detail ↗
American Board of Trial Advocates, ABOTA

ABOTA Member, Phoenix Chapter

Invitation-Only · Member since 2017 · Executive Board

What Membership Requires

  • Demonstrated jury trial experience
  • Nomination by current members
  • Peer review and national board approval

ABOTA is a national, invitation-only organization of experienced trial lawyers dedicated to preserving the civil jury trial. Membership requires nomination — attorneys cannot apply. It draws equally from plaintiff and defense lawyers, making it a genuine cross-bar assessment of trial skill. Jennifer Rebholz has been a member since 2017 and serves on the Phoenix Chapter Executive Board.

Full credential detail ↗
From the Bar

Verified peer assessments from Arizona attorneys submitted through Martindale-Hubbell’s peer review process. Jennifer holds the AV Preeminent rating, Martindale-Hubbell’s highest distinction, awarded to fewer than 5% of rated attorneys.

★★★★★
“She has tried cases with other attorneys in my firm and the reports back were that she is very capable in trial and honest in her approach. She has done both plaintiff’s work and insurance company defense work. I would recommend her for your highest rating.”
Marketing Partner · Personal Injury · 2025
★★★★★
“Jennifer has been a stellar member of the Arizona bar. She is a Certified Specialist with extensive trial experience. I have never known her to maintain anything other than high ethical standards.”
Attorney · Personal Injury · 2025
★★★★★
“A very talented lawyer and accomplished professional. She is a former president of the State Bar of Arizona and a well respected advocate. I would refer my family and friends to her.”
Senior Partner · Personal Injury · 2025

What People Ask

Questions most often asked by clients, referring attorneys, and members of the press.

Q1

What kinds of cases does Jennifer Rebholz handle?

Jennifer focuses on catastrophic injury and wrongful death matters in Arizona, including complex transportation cases, premises liability, and medical malpractice. Approximately 90% of her current practice is plaintiff-side injury and wrongful death litigation. She handles a limited number of matters as a neutral mediator or arbitrator in injury cases.

Q2

What is a catastrophic injury case?

A catastrophic injury is permanent and life-altering: traumatic brain injury, spinal cord damage, severe burns, amputation, or any harm that fundamentally changes a person’s ability to live and work. These cases are distinguished by the long-term medical, financial, and personal consequences they carry. They require a lawyer who understands not just liability, but the full scope of what has been lost.

Q3

What does it mean that Jennifer Rebholz is defense-trained?

Jennifer spent her first eighteen years of practice on the other side of personal injury cases: thirteen years as captive counsel for a major insurance company and six years as a civil defense litigator representing businesses and insurers. She knows how carriers evaluate claims, how defense teams build cases against injured people, and what drives resolution decisions. Since transitioning to plaintiff work in late 2023, that knowledge is entirely in the service of the people she represents.

Q4

Why does board certification matter when choosing a personal injury attorney?

Board certification in personal injury and wrongful death law is held by fewer than 2% of Arizona personal injury attorneys. It requires documented trial experience, peer review from both judges and opposing counsel, a written examination, and ongoing continuing legal education. It is not a directory listing or a peer-voted award. As of the most recent certification cycle, 93 attorneys in Arizona hold it. Jennifer Rebholz has held it since 2020.

Q5

What makes a personal injury case the right fit for Jennifer’s practice?

Jennifer focuses on large-loss matters where the injury is permanent, the consequences are life-altering, and the work requires someone who has tried these cases from both sides of the courtroom. She brings 35 first-chair jury trials across five Arizona counties and twenty years of civil litigation experience. Catastrophic injury, wrongful death, serious motor vehicle and trucking crashes, and complex premises liability claims are the core of her plaintiff practice.

Q6

How long does a wrongful death case take in Arizona?

Most wrongful death cases in Arizona take one to three years to resolve, depending on complexity, the number of parties involved, and whether the matter proceeds to trial. The statute of limitations is generally two years from the date of death. Complex cases involving commercial vehicles, multiple defendants, or disputed liability often require more time to investigate and prepare. Jennifer evaluates each matter individually and is direct about realistic timelines from the outset.

Q7

Does Jennifer Rebholz handle cases outside of Maricopa County?

Yes. Jennifer has tried cases in Maricopa, Pima, Coconino, Pinal, and Yavapai counties. She represents clients statewide and is admitted to practice in Arizona and the United States District Court for the District of Arizona.